Should Women Propose?

In this age of equal opportunities, a surprisingly tiny number of women pops “the questions”. According to a survey of married couples in America, only in 5% of cases it was the woman to propose, even though three quarters of Americans say that it would be fine for the woman to propose.
In an age when there are dating apps where women make the first move, a survey of men showed that only 33% thought that “whoever had the guts to do it” should propose, a tiny 4% preferred the woman to do it, and a whopping 63% preferred to retain the privilege. In another survey , only 2.8% of women said that they would be willing to propose. So, there must be lots of men and women who are happy to share the mortgage, the nappy-changing and the washing up but not the proposing.
There is not much to be nostalgic about the days when women had to weigh the chances of being proposed to by their favourite suitor against the prospect of being “left on the shelf”, and shy men who dithered for too long, ended up seeing their sweetheart at the altar with somebody else. So, why is men’s role in proposing still so entrenched?
Women fear that, if they propose, they will seen as desperate or unfeminine.They also worry that, later in the marriage, they will doubt if the man really wanted it.
For the men, it’s a matter of feeling deprived of agency, emasculated, rushed, and that they’ve had their “thunder stolen”.
With social media broadcasting every events of people’s lives and opening them to public scrutiny, it’s probably even harder for a couple to take risks and break the mould.
Witnesses of the fact that this isn’t only a modern conundrum, some Irish and Scottish traditions, dating respectively to the 5th and the 13th century, allow women to propose on the 29th of February.
Unfortunately, the next leap year will be in 2020. Much too long to wait. So, if you are a woman and wish to pop the question this Christmas Eve ( according to a survey , this is men’s favourite time for proposing, while for women it’s Valentine’s Day and, of course, the anniversary of the first meeting), here are my suggestions:

  1. No surprises:  while you think you have dropped hints, he might not have caught them. Give him plenty of time to think about what he is going to say and how (there are no masculine patterns of behaviour yet for a man who has been proposed to).
  2. Keep it low-key: if you are going to break with tradition and do the deed, it makes no sense to reintroduce tradition in the form of surprise, rings, romantic venue, etc. If you did, he would really feel like you are stealing his thunder. As you are doing something new and untraditional, do it in a new and untraditional way. The ring, the romance, the music, are traditional ways to speak women’s love language. Speaking a man’s love language probably looked more like dropping the question casually, possibly while driving or doing some other activity which doesn’t allow eye contact.

Most of us, men and women, won’t be proposing this year, but there is a lot we can do to make life easier and happier for those who are thinking of doing so: respect their decisions, do not judge, and always, always be kind.

Would you propose or would you rather be proposed to?


Photo from Maxpixel

10 Comments Add yours

  1. This is a wonderful topic and gives us so much to think about. I’ll try to be 100% honest. I think it’s definitely okay for the woman to propose. There’s no difference there. Would I propose? I do have the guts, for sure, but I would be afraid of being accused of rushing things, especially by people outside the relationship. I would be worried about what people would say, to be honest. I’m not proud of that. Anyway, I was proposed to last March and we’re getting married next year. I think he is happy to have proposed to me and I know he’s definitely tradicional when it comes to that. Thank you for such a wonderful post. 😊❤️

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Congratulations, Cheila! And thank you for your honest comment. I think that you’ve hit the nail on the head: it’s the judgement of the people around us that’s most often the problem. And not just about proposing, but many other things!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I always try to be honest even if I don’t like my own opinion. Does that make sense? The feminist in me is ashamed to care about what other people would think about it but it’s how I feel.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. I think that your honesty is fantastic! If everyone was honest, we would realise that we are not alone in so many things… Thank you, Cheila, and have a lovely day! X

          Liked by 1 person

  2. I proposed to my husband on a leap year day. We were living in two different countries at the time, and I sent an email asking him and he replied ‘yes’. And that was that. We kind of knew it was going to happen, but one of us needed to take the plunge. I don’t think it matters who asks.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for sharing your engagement story, Barbara. I’m of the same opinion as you, that it doesn’t matter who proposes (or how they do it). One person in the couple is likely to be a bit braver than the other, and that person isn’t always the man!


  3. Elena says:

    This is a great topic, but… how is it anyone’s business except the two people concerned? I don’t understand the argument of “what would the others say” in this case. Two people are getting married, so how would the others know who proposed? Unless you tell them, of course, but why would you? It’s a private matter. I mean, we don’t necessarily advertise intimate goings on in the bedroom either!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. What you say makes perfect sense! Unfortunately, though, it’s become very common for people to ask who, when, where and how proposed. Some people post their ‘engagement stories’ on social media and this often fuels a competition for the most impressive/romantic/original/outrageous proposal. Even those who would rather keep the matter private, are then asked prying question or expected to reveal every detail. And this piles the pressure onto the poor man, who’s expected to propose in grand style!


      1. Elena says:

        Well, I think you can guess what my answer to those prying questions would be! 😉 It’s not like they are going to put you into an iron maiden until you confess! But I see your point how other people put themselves on display and then suffer the consequences of being judged by everyone.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. I love your attitude, Elena! We should all take a leaf out of your book! 🙂 Have a lovely Sunday x


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s